(Aug 19 NZT) Hardcore No-Party Ladder Race

"
Capper wrote:
"
Thordon wrote:
+1 to more party disabled races. The competition was intense on Kripp's stream


While I do think parties are an advantage. You have to keep in mind that Kripp and I had passed the record for highest level in previous races which had parties (Unless I'm mistaken). I think the only big advantage is that some classes are slower than others and being in a party slingshots you ahead of competition of your class.

Party of 6 Marauders vs 1 Marauder, the single Marauder will do better. So I'm kinda thinking it's somewhat fair if you can assemble a good party, you should be rewarded.


Totally agree, however, I would like to see a mix of ladders like this.

Party play is a different build sometimes than solo play. AOE's and even helping each other out.

I think with a good party team that play to be in a party, they could do even better than solo. Clearly we see that Maras are strong at leveling up early game.

Anyways great job Capper.

I think this was the best event I've seen so far, close race and fun to watch who was doing what. I had 2 live streams and playing so got a good round view of what was going on. Felt like I was watching a football game or something.
Although a bit discouraging I liked to see that the top position switched so often.

I also like that a shadow came third, which is a bit of a surprise, since I expected Maras to rule this.

Although I'm only placed 130 (well at least my char survived :P) it was a lot of fun, I guess next week is a group event so I might use that to watch some streams, not sure if I participate.
Damn, was really looking forward to this race. Did two practice runs, had my build and skill gems sorted out. 15 minutes into the race someone knocked on my door and I had to quit playing and go do something else. Oh well, hopefully there will be a lot more solo races in the future.

"
Capper wrote:
"
Thordon wrote:
+1 to more party disabled races. The competition was intense on Kripp's stream


While I do think parties are an advantage. You have to keep in mind that Kripp and I had passed the record for highest level in previous races which had parties (Unless I'm mistaken). I think the only big advantage is that some classes are slower than others and being in a party slingshots you ahead of competition of your class.

Party of 6 Marauders vs 1 Marauder, the single Marauder will do better. So I'm kinda thinking it's somewhat fair if you can assemble a good party, you should be rewarded.


It's very true that some classes are better than others at these races, and it's a pretty big deal. To allow a group to carry the weaker classes to first place is kind of ridiculous.

That's not the only problem with allowing groups. People can play solo but have friends give them quest rewards like phase run or coordinate together to skip quests in act 2 which gives them an advantage over other people playing solo.

I generally don't even bother to try to be competitive in these races when groups are involved because the playing field isn't level. When I'm playing solo while someone else is playing in a group we both might as well be playing different games with different rule sets, so what's the point?

I hope GGG considers doing mostly solo events in the future considering how competitive this race turned out to be and how much more people participated. It seems like only a very small handful of people actually want group races anyway.
Just as a party elevates other classes, it also lowers Marauder. A good Marauder should be OK solo, whereas a good witch/templar won't have a chance. Perhaps a good strategy would be to play Marauder solo while the Marauders in groups are slowed down.

Really wish I would have not died stupidly nearly an hour in with my Duelist, I wasn't doing really well (something like 31st overall when I died), but I usually finish the last 2 hours stronger than most and I had some nice gear to work with.

Rebooted as a Templar and got tons of yellow drops, all about 5+ levels lower than me and off class.

Really should practice a few times, my pace is all kinds of broken compared to the best and I'm usually 2 levels down before I hit level 7. If I can fix that, I'll be in good shape. Well, if I stop dying.
How Fusings Work: http://www.pathofexile.com/forum/view-thread/38585/page/3#p1451934

IGN: TheHammer
Last edited by TehHammer#0539 on Aug 19, 2012, 12:55:31 AM
Aug 19 Race - Aug 12 Race
Both races are patch 0.9.11
(Solo V Parties) - People placing first, Solo beat parties in every single class.

  • Marauder
    Barbie_Trolls_All (Lv 31) 5611638 Exp (Solo)
    dpspls (Lv 28) 3645811 Exp (Party)
  • Witch
    TheOneWhoKnocks (Lv 27) 3016347 Exp (Solo)
    ImAMonster (Lv 27) 3358100 Exp (Party)
  • Shadow
    ShuuheiHCR (Lv 28) 3713736 Exp (Solo)
    Krippdeath (Lv 27) 3357529 Exp (Party)
  • Ranger
    TeamSolo (Lv 26) 2942967 Exp (Solo)
    SpicyArrow (Lv 25) 2500722 Exp
    (In Party enabled league but could have been soloing)
  • Duelist
    TheWorst (Lv 26) 2857285 Exp (Solo)
    Irate_Butter (Lv 25) 2446930 Exp
    (In Party enabled league but could have been soloing)
  • Templar
    Nurai (Lv 26) 2849971 Exp (Solo)
    Nawtseth (Lv 25) 2434879 Exp
    (In Party enabled league but could have been soloing)

So what can we see here? We can clearly see that 5/6 of the people in the solo league did better than people in the party league & the ONE CLASS that did worse just happens to be the same person who gave up in the solo league with like 40 minutes to spare because no witches were on the ladder. How can you say this is not competitive with group play when the figures dont back you up in ANY class.
Seriously? What is even fun about solo races? Why do you want to play 3 whole hours by yourself, it gets old really fast, I think (and I know many people feel the same way because they have said it to me) that group play should be encouraged in games, so there is no reason why it shouldnt be better than solo.

I got more exp than I got in a group, and if I was in last weeks race (which had party enabled) I would have been the first place ranger anyway - this is also true for every class when you compare them to last race. You can still compete and beat parties if you are solo, but that doesnt mean the same people wont do well in either solo or group play.

Spoiler
Unfortunately I need a few more events to make better comparisons, because the last 3 hour event that I placed in was 0.9.10 where I got only level 25 (In a group)
Is the ladder still available to view? i went to bed and i cannot seem to find it. Thanks
Comparing this race to last race I don't think is an accurate comparison, given that Arioc, Duolc, and Metronomy died, 3 of the typical party members taking first of their class.

If you compare to the august 5th race, you'll see ranger, duelist, and templar all at level 28. None of those classes broke level 26 this race solo, and there was a ton of competition this race.
The shadow I'm pretty amazed about, I'm wondering if the player just got really lucky on some drops or discovered an amazing racing spec for shadow that nobody else is aware of.

I'm not surprised at the marauder results at all. Marauders are easily the strongest racing class compared to the other classes, having the tankiness and damage of a melee class with the safety of a ranged class through ground slam.

Based on these results, even though it's only 1 sample, it's pretty reasonable to claim that if all classes were as good at racing as the marauder is, there would be an extremely clear advantage for coordinated parties.

Just because you don't enjoy playing solo doesn't mean everybody doesn't Metronomy. I'm sure I'm not the only one who was having a lot of fun this race playing solo, especially since it actually felt a lot more like a competition than the other races.
"
cludo wrote:
Is the ladder still available to view? i went to bed and i cannot seem to find it. Thanks

http://poestatistics.com/events/aug-19-3h-hc-race/
http://poetools.com/ - PATH OF EXILE TOOLS
"
kompostownik wrote:
"
cludo wrote:
Is the ladder still available to view? i went to bed and i cannot seem to find it. Thanks

http://poestatistics.com/events/aug-19-3h-hc-race/


Thanks I managed 53rd :)
First attempt at speed race.
I LOVE playing in a party. It has great mechanics and companionship. BUT having said that I believe solo events like this are a LOT better at testing your own abilities. Please GGG give us a /myladder and /myclass command for the races.

Perhaps we could have these races alternate weekly.

This race certainly put me through the mill. I easily got the worst drops in this race compared to any other race I've run. I was literally collecting whites to sell for wisdoms and blues for transmutations. I didn't get a single Alchemy or Chance orb. And then to make matters worse the rolls I got from the transmutations (3 in total by level 19)were all sooooo FAIL.

Eventually 30 or so minutes (01:30am) before the end in a moment of frustration at weaver I failed to hit the "Alt F4" bringing an end to my race.

Fatigue/frustration/FUN! damn right I'll do it all over again and again.

I'm BACK :)

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info