Guilds between PoE1 and PoE2

In case those others in this thread haven't seen it, Jonathan Rogers had said guilds (and therefore the MTX within) are not carrying over into EA for launch, but the details were vague so there isn't confirmation whether or not it will/won't in the future, but at EA launch it won't be there. He answered this briefly in the Korean interview with Kakao games. Disappointing, since I'd presume there will be users who will feel like this goes against their MTX transfer promise, but if I'm honest I had held back on investing into a guild because I hadn't seen it clear cut. I feel for those who have :(.

"

Reflexsavehalf#4092 wrote:

In case those others in this thread haven't seen it, Jonathan Rogers had said guilds (and therefore the MTX within) are not carrying over into EA for launch, but the details were vague so there isn't confirmation whether or not it will/won't in the future, but at EA launch it won't be there.

OK, so it's just a limitation of Early Access, and not confirmed to a permanent thing for PoE2. That makes sense; PoE2 isn't finished yet, so support for things like guilds are just further down the road map. I would assume that your guild mtx will carry over (where targets exist) just like all your other mtx once there are targets for them, i.e. once guilds exist in the new game. No need to panic just yet, or to assume the worst of a company that's got a proven track record of doing right by their customers; GGG will clarify when the details are locked down. They're just focused on what's actually launching in PoE2 atm.

"

LeJC#4882 wrote:

That's why I posted it in the help and information forum at first, but they moved it here.

Yeah, I also made a post asking about more information on guild creation in Help and Information, where it belongs, but they shoved it into General Discussion which is basically just the staff ignoring the query and throwing it into the trash. Kind of weird that there's still zero information about guild creation whatsoever aside from "they won't transfer from PoE1 (yet?)." Are guilds even going to be a thing at PoE2 EA/launch? It would be nice to have some answers

Here is the answer from Jonathan.
https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxKmIqkmyYjjyp1VOJbFQCQSkhG_KDu7LG

Guild MTX aren't transferred between PoE1 and PoE2. He wanted to do that, but they they didn't have the time. It's a technical issue.

So that answers it. The guilds are different, we will need to start over.